Prenatal Special Edition

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

- - - - - - - - - - - -

The Prenatal Edition of the Newsletter.

 

As many of you know over the last year there was a new DS prenatal screening test released and this was combined with a recommendation from the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, for doctors to offer the new, safer screening procedure to all pregnant women, regardless of age.

 

 

My personal feelings and experience:

 

Josh's condition slipped through the triple screen and the level 2 ultra sound test undetected.  Only several hours after his birth did we know that Josh had DS.  After hearing stories from parents that had positive prenatal diagnosis, we became aware of how difficult it must be to have this knowledge and spend the rest of the pregnancy trying to grasp the reality and think of the future.

 

The positives of prenatal diagnosis allow parents to educate themselves or arrange to have appropriate medical staff on hand during delivery.  But for the most part, the results are not being used for such preparation. 

 

The test is a technological advance and scientific achievement that I’m not opposed to.  However, like most technological advancements, it moved too fast for common sense and the laws to keep up with and has unintended consequences. 

 

We feel that it is important to have resources available to families that receive positive prenatal diagnosis for DS.  A sterile reading about DS from the clinician doesn't come close to the reality of the true situation.  Hopefully we can fill the technological gap with our increased efforts to raise awareness and acceptance.

 

 

 

Down syndrome test labelled faulty and risky
Stuff
Thu, 26 Apr 2007 1:06 PM PDT
Methods of testing unborn babies for Down syndrome are inaccurate and increase the risk of miscarriages, a ministerial advisory group has found.

 

Prenatal Test Puts Down Syndrome in Hard Focus
New York Times
Tue, 08 May 2007 7:53 PM PDT
A group of parents are trying to present positive perspectives on having a child with Down syndrome.

"United Arab Emirates Ministry of Health To Decide Whether To Legalize Abortion if Fetus Has Certain Genetic Conditions"
You can view the full article online by clicking here.

 

 

From an author of Gifts (the book): 

 

Dear Friends and Family,

 

As many of you know, I contributed an essay to a book entitled Gifts:

Mothers Reflect on How Children with Down Syndrome Enrich Their Lives.  The first edition of this book was released in November, published by Booksurge and available only over the internet.  It was available for three weeks before a major publisher picked up the option.  The first edition is no longer available.

The major publisher Woodbine House is releasing the second edition this spring. Gifts can be ordered here (http://giftsds.segullah.org/  ) by clicking on the "order now" option on the homepage.   Pre-ordered books will be shipped in mid-May and the book will be in bookstores in June, earlier than the anticipated July release date due to great demand.  All royalties go towards purchasing books for new parents.

I can not stress enough how amazing, and how important, this book is.  The book includes the essays of 63 contributors, along with a forward by parenting guru Martha Sears, R.N., herself a mother of an adult son with Down syndrome.  Beverly Beckam of the Boston Globe comments that "Gifts is honest and life affirming" while George Will of Newsweek remarks, "This fine book helps dispel the fear and misinformation about Down syndrome that many parents and prospective parents face."  When I received my copy, I greedily devoured every essay, and found the experience amazing and uplifting.

As you know, Vincent & I learned of Gabriella's diagnosis while I was pregnant.  We were fortunate enough to have some excellent mentors, Marie & Tom, parents of Keith whom we've known for years, and Kathi and Chick, parents of Lizzie whom we met after the diagnosis.  Despite their excellent support, the time period post-diagnosis in some ways was a scary, uncertain time.

The Difficulties of Diagnosis

There are many people receiving a diagnosis of Down syndrome who do not have the benefit of ever having known anyone with Down syndrome.  In addition, recent research for Harvard Medical School by Dr. Brian Skotko has revealed that many doctors are quite deficient in the way they deliver the news of a diagnosis to parents.  These doctors (though of course not all) may deliver the news abruptly, may provide inadequate, incorrect, or overly negative information, may pressure a woman to terminate, or may be simply incapable of providing hope to parents.  (http://www.news.harvard.edu/gazette/2005/03.03/27-down.html)  This deficiency may be contributing in part to the estimated 85 to 90% termination rate for a prenatal diagnosis of Down syndrome.  To complicate matters, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), while ignoring the deficiencies noted above, has issued new practice guidelines for prenatal testing which will identify many more unborn babies with Down syndrome.  (http://www.acog.org/from_home/publications/press_releases/nr01-02-07-1.cfm) In addition, there are new, non-invasive testing procedures on the horizon which will provide a confirmed diagnosis of Down syndrome much earlier in pregnancy.  (http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn11095-noninvasive-downs-syndrome-test-shows-promise.html)  Sadly, many women face family, social, and medical pressure to terminate.

The Advances for People with Down Syndrome

The issues concerning the way in which a diagnosis is delivered come at a time when medical and social advances are providing individuals with Down syndrome the opportunities to lead healthier, happier, and more productive lives than at any time in history.  There have been advances in cardiology and other surgical medicines which have drastically improved the health of many individuals with Down syndrome.  In addition, automatic newborn screening for hypothyroidism and thyroid medications, as well as automatic screening schedules for a variety of issues, are working together to use "preventive medicine" to help many individuals with Down syndrome.  Finally, parents and health care providers are utilizing a growing and shared body of medical knowledge available through the internet.  My Gabriella, had she been born decades ago, would have been severely mentally retarded and very ill due to heart and thyroid issues, but today these issues have been removed as obstacles due to modern surgery and simple medication.

With the beginning of Early Intervention, as well as its maturation over the past decades, young children are getting the help they need in the crucial young years of brain development.  Therapists and parents alike are learning methods that can help children start achieving their potential early in life.  With the development of local groups and internet information exchanges, parents are able to discuss the best techniques and strategies and often bring ideas to the therapists.  Sign language has emerged as a particularly useful tool for our children, showing us that even as little ones they have a voice even if it is not in the form we expect.

With the protection of the law and the blossoming of understanding, many children with Down syndrome are attending school with their typical peers, benefiting from the interaction and in turn exposing many to the humanity of a child with Down syndrome.  In adulthood, many people with Down syndrome hold jobs, live independently and enjoy recreational opportunities in their communities.  People with Down syndrome do face challenges, but with family and societal support can lead fulfilling lives and many can give back to the community.  (For more information, link to the national organizations:

http://www.ndsccenter.org/  or http://www.ndss.org/ )

Solutions

Many individuals and organizations have worked to reduce the difficulties of diagnosis.  Some national organizations have provided training materials to local groups, and many local organizations have created outreach programs to train local health care providers.   In addition, using grant money from the Kennedy Foundation, two organizations, the NDSC (National Down Syndrome Congress) and the NDSS (National Down Syndrome Society), are actively making plans to address the deficiency in delivering the news of a diagnosis on a national level.

(http://www1.ndss.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=1895&Itemid=5

Plans are underway to address this situation at a governmental level as well.  Senator Sam Brownback (R., Kansas), Senator Edward M. Kennedy (D.,Mass), and others have introduced a bipartisan bill entitled "The Prenatally Diagnosed Conditions Awareness Act" (S. 609, H.R. 1353), which aims to ensure that patients receiving a positive test diagnosis for Down syndrome (or other prenatally diagnosed conditions) have timely access to scientifically sound information and adequate support services.  The bill was introduced in the House as well and is currently in committee.

http://www.geneticalliance.org/ws_display.asp?filter=%7B1F2FE2CA%2D1CE7%2D4D60%2D8758%2DCD5C45AD0EAC%7D

 (Genetic Alliance summary) 

http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/z?c109:S.609  (the actual bill)

The Gifts book provides newly diagnosed parents with first-hand stories from other parents, most of whom once feared a Down syndrome diagnosis.  It provides that crucial parental perspective so often missing when parents are grappling with a diagnosis.  It is honest, in some places gut-wrenchingly honest, but provides that element of hope parents desperately need.  Gifts was the dream of two visionary mothers of children with Down syndrome, who wished to share with all newly diagnosed parents the feelings they experienced in raising their children with Down syndrome, providing the hope so often missing when physicians deliver a diagnosis.  Their voices were soon joined by other mothers' voices, creating a chorus of voices celebrating the lives of children with Down syndrome. The authors have backgrounds as varied as those of the people of the nation, representing a variety of ethnicities, religious beliefs or lack thereof, and political beliefs, including both pro-life and pro-choice women. 

It is our goal to provide a copy of Gifts to every newly diagnosed parent.  The first step in doing so is to provide complimentary copies to medical providers who deliver the diagnosis to parents.  At a national level, the NDSC will have a presence at the ACOG convention in May, where they will have the opportunity to provide information and literature to the 4,000 to 5,000 attendees.  Thanks to a generous contribution by Sandra McElwee, Gifts contributor, there will be 300 copies of the Gifts book available to attendees.   

At a local level, Virtua Health and the Southern New Jersey Perinatal

Cooperative are jointly sponsoring a seminar at the end of May for various local medical providers in Southern New Jersey entitled "Emotionally Supporting the Family of a Newborn with Down Syndrome."  Medical professionals who have experienced receiving a Down syndrome diagnosis are presenting the seminar, which will include advice for compassionately delivering the news to parents of a newborn and which will cover prenatal screening.   The BUDS (Bringing Up Down Syndrome) group (http://www.bringingupdownsyndrome.org/) has generously agreed to purchase 100 copies of the Gifts book to provide complimentary copies to the attendees. 

After learning of the situation facing newly diagnosed families, if you desire to help in this endeavor, you may donate money to either our local BUDS group or the national group NDSC, with the check and cover letter earmarking your donation to purchase Gifts books for the ACOG convention or the local seminar.  Many parents will benefit from this generosity.  I have drafted and included on the next pages two alternative cover letters for your donation which you may find easy to use and which will ensure that your contribution supports this cause. (If you live in the local area it would probably be better to support the local effort/ BUDS group and outside the area the NDSC.) [message from Chris:  Let me know if you want a copy of these letters I didn’t include them here]

Whether you simply pick up a copy of the Gifts book for your own reading, or whether you take the additional step of sending earmarked funds to BUDS or the NDSC, I thank you so much for your support of newly diagnosed families.

 

 

 

- - - - - - - - - - - -